ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHY
Brown, C. & Groves, J. (2010). New media, enduring values : How three news organisations managed change in an age of uncertainty. Electronic News, 4(3), 131-145.doi: 10. 1177/1931243110380182
Carrie Brown is an assistant professor at the University of Memphis. She studies changing newsroom and social media. Jonathan Groves is an assistant professor at Drury University and his research interests include organisational change, social media, and the effect of the Internet on traditional news media. This case study uses theory about organisational culture and leadership and multiple sources of evidence to evaluate the effectiveness of an initiative by three news organisations to bring the core principles of journalism to life on the web. To understand more about the factors that shape organisational change in newsrooms, Brown and Groves developed three research questions. Each news organisation is asked to develop an online project to exemplify one of three key values: verifying the accuracy of information, finding ways to make important news more relevant, and creating a public forum for discussion. Brown and Groves use the studies from the project to indicate that legacy media staffs are ready to change, but leaders must play a role in providing a safe environment and resources to reduce learning anxiety and build confidence in the ability to change. The authors use many citations in their article to increase the credibility of their views. They also point out that values of journalism should be maintained.
ABC News Online, 28 October, 2011.
Headlines on the ABC News website, reported that Qantas airline is in dispute with its pilots, ground staff and licensed engineers over pay and conditions, as well as the outsourcing of jobs overseas. ABC aims to present the truth, so the news is mainly focused on the dispute between the airline's board and the unions. The journalist who writes this news did not choose a side to stand on. As Qantas chief executive Alan Joyce used the airline's annual general meeting in Sydney to talk about the industrial actions taken by the unions, he apologised to those customers that have been impacted and warned unions he will not give in to their demands. The ongoing union action had cost the airline $15 million a week in lost revenue. As the situation is getting worse and worse, other newspaper like the Sydney Morning Herald, used several paragraphs to talk about should Prime Minister Julia Gillard intervene in the dispute. ABC did not discuss whether it is good or not for the federal government to help resolving the conflicts, the news just reported that Liberal Premiers urged Julia Gillard to intervene in the long-running dispute. To report a news, ABC is mostly impartial and seldom having a particular stance. Its news is more credible than that of other newspapers as it is one of the public media.
Sky News Online, 28 October, 2011.
TV news report that Prime Minister Julia Gillard says she is keeping a close eye on the Qantas dispute. The government has been urged to take action in the escalating war between the company and its workers over pay negotiations, with continued strike action causing chaos for passengers. Sky News quoted a number of sayings of the opposition in order to support the view that the government should take actions to resolve and fix the conflicts. Nationals federal leader Warren Truss accused the government of being a passive observer during a national crisis is a waste of everybody's time. Although this opinion is quoted from the Nationals federal leader, it also represents the stance of Sky News on this social issue. Sky News is one of the commercial media, it aims to maximise its profits. Therefore, the news is written to cater to tastes of its potential readers. As people pay for what they want to see, Sky News would have some particular opinions to suit the stance of the majority in the public. That is the reason why ABC news would be more credible than Sky news.
Morrison, J. (2011, September 21). Qantas strike: who did it hurt? [Podcast radio programme]. Australia: 2UE954 News Talk. Retrieved October 27, 2011 from http://www.2ue.com.au/blogs/2ue-blog/
Jason has twice been the recipient of the Brian White Memorial Award for journalistic achievement. Before returning to radio, he held the senior positions of Chief of Staff and News Editor at TEN Television Network for four years.In the radio programme, Jason Morrison shared his opinions on the social issue of Qantas strike. Unions claim strikes send a message who is in charge, but Jason says, actually, the strike is punishing the customers, the people who are on the union's side. Jason agrees that Qantas, as an Australian company, the base should be in Australia. However, he does not think that workers calling a strike is a good way to send their message to the CEO. Jason argued that the strike would bring inconvenience to the public. Even most Australians would agree that Qantas can do some more to improve and respond to the pressure from the workers, they must not like their flights being disrrupted. From Jason's point of view, calling a strike is not a way to send a message, but a way to destroy the brand of Qantas and the economy of Australia. What Jason talks about Qantas strikes in the radio programme is very different from the same news story reported by ABC. ABC aims to report the fact and what happening in Australia. The opinion of the journalist is not easy to find in the news reported by ABC. On the other hand, the radio programme by Jason Morrison can be full of controversy. Audiences can evaluate or criticise the opinions he shares. On that news talk website, there would be some audiences sharing the comments after listening to the radio programme. As creating a public forum for discussion is one of the key values in the modern society, such radio programme and websites are quite successful.
Reference List
ABC News Online, 28 October, 2011.
Brown, C. & Groves, J. (2010). New media, enduring values : How three news organisations managed change in an age of uncertainty. Electronic News, 4(3), 131-145.doi: 10. 1177/1931243110380182
Morrison, J. (2011, September 21). Qantas strike: who did it hurt? [Podcast radio programme]. Australia: 2UE954 News Talk. Retrieved October 27, 2011 from http://www.2ue.com.au/blogs/2ue-blog/
Sky News Online, 28 October, 2011.